By Paul R Salmon FCILT, FSCM
The Supply Chain Operations Reference (SCOR) model – first developed by the Supply Chain Council and now maintained by APICS – might be more than 25 years old, but it remains one of the most comprehensive frameworks for describing, measuring, and improving supply chain performance.
In the context of UK Defence, its value has arguably increased in recent years as the environment becomes more joint, agile, and contested.
1. A Common Language for Complex Supply Chains
Defence’s Challenge: The UK Defence supply chain spans military and civilian, national and allied, in-service and deployed operations. Different parts of the organisation often speak in different process languages. SCOR’s Role: SCOR’s Plan–Source–Make–Deliver–Return–Enable process categories provide a universal vocabulary. This supports: Alignment between DE&S, Front Line Commands, industry partners, and allies. Clearer requirements definition for support contracts. Cross-organisation performance comparison without losing context.
2. Process Standardisation Across Domains
Defence Reality: Land, Air, Maritime, and Joint Enablers all have unique cultures, systems, and supply models, leading to silos. SCOR Advantage: Offers a baseline process map that can be adapted to each domain while still enabling apples-to-apples performance tracking. Example: Standardising the “Return” process for reverse logistics, whether that’s aircraft components or field catering units.
3. Robust, Proven Metrics
Defence Need: Decision-makers require evidence-based performance data to justify investments and optimise availability. SCOR Solution: Comes with a structured performance hierarchy and KPIs, such as: Reliability (Perfect Order Fulfilment) Responsiveness (Order Fulfilment Cycle Time) Agility (Upside Supply Chain Flexibility) Cost (Supply Chain Management Cost) Asset Management (Cash-to-Cash Cycle Time) These are easily adapted for Defence-specific metrics, such as equipment availability, mission readiness, or sustainment cost per platform.
4. Benchmarking Capability
Why Important in Defence: With increased scrutiny on value-for-money, Defence needs to compare its performance with both other nations and the commercial sector. SCOR’s Contribution: Enables direct benchmarking against industry and allied partners using a common standard—valuable for NATO interoperability and partner assessments.
5. Agility in a Contested Environment
Operational Reality: Supply chains are now operating in environments of disruption—pandemics, geopolitical tension, contested logistics in theatre. SCOR Relevance: The agility and resilience measures embedded in SCOR can help Defence stress-test its supply chains, model disruptions, and develop mitigation plans.
6. Bridge Between Strategic and Tactical
Defence Gap: Often there’s a disconnect between high-level sustainment strategies and day-to-day logistics execution. SCOR’s Edge: Provides a framework linking strategy to execution, allowing leadership to: Understand how a strategic change (e.g., stock re-brigading, asset pooling) translates into process changes. Ensure those changes are monitored and measured consistently.
7. Enablement for Digital Transformation
Digital Push in Defence: The MOD is investing in digital twins, predictive analytics, and AI-enabled decision support. SCOR’s Support: SCOR’s structured process and data definitions can underpin these digital initiatives by: Creating data standards for analytics and AI. Providing a model for integrating systems like ERP, inventory forecasting tools, and asset management platforms.
Bottom Line
The SCOR model’s value for UK Defence lies in its ability to:
Unify language across a fragmented enterprise. Standardise processes without stifling domain-specific needs. Provide a proven measurement framework adaptable to Defence metrics. Enable benchmarking against industry and allies. Support agility and resilience in contested environments. Bridge strategy and operations, and Anchor digital transformation in a recognised best-practice framework.
In an era of tighter budgets, contested supply lines, and increasing demands on readiness, SCOR’s structured approach offers Defence a time-tested yet future-proof tool for understanding, measuring, and improving the supply chain that underpins military capability.
SCOR Model Mapped to UK Defence Context
SCOR Process
Defence Equivalent
Examples in UK Defence
Plan
Operational & Strategic Sustainment Planning
– Defence Support Chain Planning Tool outputs feeding readiness planning.- Joint operational sustainment plans (Air, Land, Maritime).- Force generation timelines and NATO readiness reporting.- Aligning stock levels with defence planning assumptions (DPAs).
Source
Defence Procurement & Supply Sourcing
– DE&S category strategies for platforms, spares, and consumables.- Single Source Procurement (SSP) with primes.- Framework agreements for commodities (e.g., Class IX).- Partnering arrangements with NATO nations for shared sourcing.
Make
Maintenance, Repair, Overhaul, and Build (MRO & Manufacturing)
– Platform depth maintenance at Defence MRO hubs (e.g., DM Gosport for maritime).- In-theatre repair and refurbishment facilities.- Defence Munitions production lines.- 3D printing of components in deployed locations.
Deliver
Distribution & Theatre Sustainment
– Strategic movement via RAF Air Mobility Force.- Defence Fulfilment Centre (MOD Donnington) operations.- In-theatre resupply convoys (land) or replenishment at sea (RAS).- Distribution to allies under NATO Support & Procurement Agency (NSPA) agreements.
Return
Reverse Logistics, Recovery, and Disposal
– Returning unserviceable items for repair via Joint Support Chain Services.- Repatriating unused munitions or hazardous materials.- Disposal of obsolete kit through Defence Equipment Sales Authority (DESA).- Recovery of damaged platforms in theatre.
Enable
Support Functions & Enablers
– Defence Support Digital backbone (LogIS, MJDI, JAMES).- Support cost modelling (SMAF, LCC/WLC tools).- Performance management & KPI reporting.- Data stewardship and master data management for NSNs.- Training and professional development (CILT, DE&S Academy).
Why This Mapping Works
Direct relevance – It ties each SCOR process to a tangible MOD activity, making it easier to adopt without re-learning the model. Benchmarking ready – Defence can use the same SCOR categories when comparing its performance to commercial best practice or NATO allies. Supports interoperability – Allies using SCOR (e.g., US DoD in some logistics areas) will be speaking the same process language. Aligns with Defence Digital goals – SCOR’s structure gives the right data hierarchy for digital twin development and predictive analytics.
Leave a Reply